Ten Major League Baseball games on Thursday's slate offer sharp parlay value. Here are the best combinations to target today.
Thursday's Major League Baseball Parlay Picks - May 7, 2026
A massive ten-game Major League Baseball Thursday slate gives us plenty of angles to work with. From early afternoon first pitches to a late-night West Coast closer, there are several spots where the market looks beatable. Let's break down the best parlay combinations for today's action.
Game-by-Game Analysis
Texas Rangers @ New York Yankees (1:36 PM ET)
The Yankees open as -133 favourites at home, which feels reasonable at Yankee Stadium. The -1.5 run line at +150 on FanDuel is the standout number here - getting plus money on a favourite to win by two or more is genuine value. The total sitting at 8.5 is a moderate line for this matchup, and the Under at -108 on DraftKings looks like the safer side if pitching holds up. For parlay purposes, the Yankees -1.5 at +150 is an attractive inclusion given the plus-money attached to a home favourite.
Minnesota Twins @ Washington Nationals (2:06 PM ET)
This game features one of the most interesting lines on the board. The Washington Nationals are listed as -108 FAVOURITES on FanDuel over the Minnesota Twins, with Minnesota at -105 on Fanatics. Essentially a pick'em, but the Nationals getting home-side juice in a near-even matchup creates some interesting value. The total is set at 9, and at a neutral-pricing game this could go either way. We'll lean Twins ML at -105 (Fanatics) as a value-side play given Minnesota's general roster quality.
Cleveland Guardians @ Kansas City Royals (3:11 PM ET)
The Guardians at +123 on Bally Bet as underdogs against the Royals is a number worth noting. Kansas City is juiced to -141 on theScore Bet, which feels like an overreaction. The Under 9 at +100 on FanDuel - even-money on a totals bet - is a clear value flag. Getting even money on an under in a divisional matchup where both clubs tend to keep things tight is worth targeting. This even-money Under is one of the better value spots on the entire slate.
New York Mets @ Colorado Rockies (4:11 PM ET)
Coors Field is always a unique environment, and the total sitting at 10.5 reflects that. The Over 10.5 at -120 on Bally Bet is expensive, but the Under 10.5 at +105 on theScore Bet is excellent value. Getting plus money on the Under at Coors might seem counterintuitive, but 10.5 is a high enough line that pitching and bullpen performance can bring it under. The Mets are -145 favourites, and their -1.5 spread at +108 on FanDuel is another plus-money gem if you believe they win comfortably.
Pittsburgh Pirates @ Arizona Diamondbacks (4:41 PM ET)
This is a genuinely tight matchup with Arizona at -104 on FanDuel and Pittsburgh at -110 on BetMGM - essentially a coin flip. The spread markets reflect that uncertainty too, with both sides priced at run-line plus money. The Pirates ML at -110 offers a slight lean for a team that may be undervalued on the road.
Baltimore Orioles @ Miami Marlins (7:41 PM ET)
The Marlins as -118 home favourites over the Orioles at -105 on BetMGM for Baltimore is an interesting split. The Orioles +105 as underdogs on BetMGM stands out as value - Baltimore has the roster talent to win this outright, and plus money against a Marlins team that has struggled makes this appealing for parlay inclusion.
Athletics @ Philadelphia Phillies (7:41 PM ET)
The Phillies are firm -133 favourites at home and the -1.5 spread at +155 on Bally Bet is exceptional value for a team expected to win comfortably at Citizens Bank Park. Philadelphia is one of the stronger home teams in the National League, and the Athletics continue to be one of the weaker sides in the American League. The Phillies -1.5 at +155 is arguably the best single value play on today's board.
Tampa Bay Rays @ Boston Red Sox (8:11 PM ET)
Tampa Bay at -1.5 for +170 on Bally Bet is massive plus money for a road favourite covering the run line. The Rays being listed as road favourites at +105 on theScore Bet suggests the market respects their pitching, but Boston at -120 on BetMGM as home dogs is intriguing too. The Under 8.5 at -115 on DraftKings suggests a pitchers' duel is expected.
St. Louis Cardinals @ San Diego Padres (11:11 PM ET)
The Cardinals at +150 on theScore Bet as ML underdogs is the biggest underdog value on the late slate. San Diego at -175 on BetMGM is heavily juiced. For parlay purposes, the Cardinals +1.5 at a reasonable price is safer, but the +150 ML is genuinely tempting as a standalone value play.
Recommended Parlay Combinations
Parlay 1 - The Plus-Money Power Parlay (3 legs)
This parlay stacks three spread/run-line legs where we're getting plus money on the favoured side - a rare and valuable spot in Major League Baseball betting.
- New York Yankees -1.5 (+150) - FanDuel - Home favourites at plus money on the run line is too good to pass up at Yankee Stadium.
- Philadelphia Phillies -1.5 (+155) - Bally Bet - The best value play on the board. Phillies as strong home favourites covering against the Athletics at plus money is exceptional.
- New York Mets -1.5 (+108) - FanDuel - Mets as road favourites at Coors getting plus money to cover the run line adds another plus-price leg.
Three plus-money run-line legs combining for a massive combined price. Even hitting two of three keeps you in profit on a unit stake.
Parlay 2 - The Value Underdog Moneyline Parlay (3 legs)
Sometimes the market misprices underdogs, and today's slate has a few spots that look generous.
- Baltimore Orioles ML (+105) - BetMGM - Near-even money for a team with real roster quality against a struggling Marlins side.
- Cleveland Guardians Under 9 (+100) - FanDuel - Even-money on a divisional Under is a standout value flag. This line deserves to be -115 at minimum.
- Minnesota Twins ML (-105) - Fanatics - Getting the Twins at essentially pick'em pricing in a game where the market can't separate these two clubs.
A sensible three-leg parlay mixing an underdog ML, an even-money total, and a near-even favourite for a solid combined price.
Parlay 2 - The Late Slate Special (2 legs)
For bettors who prefer a tighter, sharper two-leg night parlay focused on the evening games.
- Philadelphia Phillies -1.5 (+155) - Bally Bet - The anchor of any Thursday parlay. Plus money on a home favourite covering is the top value play of the day.
- Tampa Bay Rays -1.5 (+170) - Bally Bet - The Rays covering as road favourites at +170 is a high-risk, high-reward addition. If Tampa Bay's pitching advantage holds, this run line covers with room to spare.
Two legs, both at significant plus money - this two-leg parlay offers outstanding combined value for a smaller, focused stake.
Best Value Flag of the Day
Cleveland Guardians Under 9 at +100 (FanDuel) - Getting even money on a totals bet is genuinely rare and represents a market inefficiency. The implied probability on a -110 line is 52.4% - here you're being offered 50/50 on what should be a marginally favoured outcome. This is the single sharpest value number on Thursday's Major League Baseball slate and deserves a place in any totals-focused parlay.
Bet responsibly - gambling should be entertaining, and you should only ever wager what you can afford to lose. If you need support, visit the National Council on Problem Gambling at ncpgambling.org.
